登陆注册
20282000000011

第11章

The Slav and Germanic custom, securing to every one the enjoyment of land from which to derive his means of subsistence, is the only one conformable to the rational theory of property. The generally accepted theory of property requires total reconstruction, for it rests on premises in direct antagonism with historic facts and with the very conclusions at which it seeks to arrive.

In enquiries as to the origin of property, sufficient attention has not been given to ancient historic facts, which may be called natural as everywhere springing from an instinct of justice, which seems innate in human nature. As Sir Henry Maine remarks, "theories, plausible and comprehensive, but absolutely unverified, such as the Law of Nature or the Social Compact, enjoy a universal preference over sober research into the primitive history of society and law; and they obscure the truth not only by diverting attention from the only quarter in which it can be found, but by that most real and most important influence which, when once entertained and believed in, they are enabled to exercise on the later stages of jurisprudence." (9)Thus, in order to defend the quiritary property bequeathed to us by the Romans, writers have asserted that it has existed at all times and in all places, ubique et semper ; -- whereas a closer knowledge of history shews us that the original and universal form of property was the mode of possession practised by the Slavonic and Germanic tribes, and exercised at Rome itself over the ager publicus .

The jurists, under the influence of the Digest and the Institutes, base the right of property on the occupation of a res nullius ; but we know of no period in which the soil has been a res nullius . Among hunting tribes their hunting-ground, among pastoral tribes their pasture lands, and finally among the earliest agricultural tribes the cultivated land, were always regarded as the joint property of the tribe, and no one ever conceived the idea that an individual could have any exclusive, hereditary right therein. Occupation could only create a right of property over movable objects, which were actually subject to seizure and detention. The formalities of sale among the Romans, shew that it was only applied by a comparatively recent extension to the alienation of an immovable.

In deriving the right of property solely from labour, economists are in direct opposition to the jurists and the legislations of all countries, and even to the existing organization of society, which their theories, if once admitted, would completely overthrow.

Writers, who endeavour to prove the necessity of the right of property, make use of arguments which shew that, in order to be equitable, it must be organized in the same way as among primitive nations, that is, so as to guarantee to every one a natural, inalienable right. The eminent legislator, Portalis, adducing the arguments in support of the title in the Code civil which treats of property, shews it to be necessary and legitimate by the following reasoning: -- Man can only live by his labour; in order to labour he must be able to appropriate a portion of the soil to dispose of it as he pleases; hence the right of property is necessary. Nothing can be more true; but, if property is necessary for a man to labour and live, it follows that every one should have some property. Bastiat adopts the same premises as Portalis, with no clearer perception of their consequences. "In the full force of the word," he says, "man is born a proprietor, because he is born with wants the satisfaction of which is essential to life, and with organs and faculties, the exercise of which is essential to the satisfaction of his wants." From these words of Bastiat it follows that, unless we condemn certain persons to death, we must recognize in all the right to property.

If man is born a proprietor, it is incumbent on the law to put him in a position to exercise the right recognized in him.

"Man," says Bastiat again, "lives and develops by appropriating certain objects. Appropriation is a natural, providential phenomenon, essential to life, and property is only appropriation converted into a right by labour."If appropriation is essential to life, all should be able to appropriate a portion of matter by their labour. This natural right is recognized in the allmend system, and in the ancient Germanic law, but is entirely overlooked in all legislation derived from the Roman law. "Property is not a natural, innate right," says Dalloz, a well-known jurist, "But it springs from an innate right, which right is liberty." If property is indispensable to liberty , does it not follow that all men having the right to be free, all are equally entitled to be proprietors? In fact, without property they would be dependent on those from whom they received their wage. Troplong, the great jurist of the Second Empire, in a pamphlet, La propriétéd'après le Code civil , published in 1848, in refutation of the false doctrines of the Socialists, expresses himself in these terms (p.

12): "If liberty is the basis of property, equality makes it sacred. All men being equal, and therefore equally free, every one ought to recognize in another the sovereign independence of the right." Now either this high-sounding phrase has no meaning at all, or else it signifies that we ought to secure to every one the enjoyment of property, which may guarantee his independence.

Most modern authors declare property to be a natural right. But what is a natural right, unless it be a right so inherent in human nature that no man should be able to be robbed of it, unless he has forfeited it by his conduct?

同类推荐
  • 达变权禅师语录

    达变权禅师语录

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 内家拳口诀释义

    内家拳口诀释义

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 刘氏菊谱

    刘氏菊谱

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • EMMA

    EMMA

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 毗尼日用切要香乳记

    毗尼日用切要香乳记

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 幸逢有你

    幸逢有你

    “我叫沈岩,沈阳的沈,岩石的岩。”四年前,他站在讲台上,用一口流利的英语向全班同学介绍自己,四年后,当她听到同样的介绍出自一个三岁小男孩口中,只觉得异常讽刺,“我爸爸叫沈岩,沈阳的沈,岩石的岩。”四年的感情毁于一旦,就在她心灰意冷之际,冥冥之中另一位故人出现在她生活中……“你失恋,我单身,正好凑成一对,怎样?考虑考虑?”网上相识五年,她将自己的心事毫无保留与他倾诉,面对他突然提出的要求,她束手无策失了方向……
  • 邪恶计划:过招美男团

    邪恶计划:过招美男团

    他说:女人是这世界上最麻烦的生物。她说:前面的那个男人在放屁。校园轻松斗,斗智斗勇斗美男。神秘学生会,美男成灾,她悄悄的来,悄悄的走,挥一挥匕首,不留一个活口……
  • 闲居编

    闲居编

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 天庭那些骚货们

    天庭那些骚货们

    不要问我来自哪里!问了我也不会告诉你!当下俺只想找个人好好谈一次恋爱!
  • 圣约者

    圣约者

    我是阿尔法,我是欧米伽,是昔在、今在、以后永在的全能者。——《圣临》1:8圣约者——人类开启自我救赎之路的产物。在神与魔的战争中,背负着全人类的命运。在动乱的世界,寻找自己的出路。我是始,我是终,是昔在、今在、以后永在的全能者。这是一本·都市·奇幻·异能·神魔·小说前方高能,请慢行~
  • 天妖皇

    天妖皇

    三千美娇娘,相助打天下。醉卧美人膝,醒掌天下权。修真版的《西游记》、《封神演义》,妖艳版的金庸、古龙群侠传,讲述一个妖族少年的成长历程。
  • 强者的天堂

    强者的天堂

    古惑仔中陈浩南义薄云天魔法世界中各种魔法盛宴火影忍者忍术纷眼花缭乱死神中各种爆发层次不穷.....................追杀与反杀组织对战组织在这样一个世界中萌发着友情,爱情各种元素交汇在一起这里是一个强者的天堂,弱者的地狱,你准备好了吗?
  • 重生平淡生活

    重生平淡生活

    重生,林秦想做的只是拯救自己,让那些爱自己人能幸福平淡的生活。就算你是重生者,这个世界上和你样优秀的人不多也不少,少数人甚至比重生者还要优秀。不是只要是美女看到你都要嫁给你,她们有很多的选择。此小说比较贴近大部分人的生活,无太多阴谋、暴力。不喜勿入,谢谢!
  • 助妻为乐

    助妻为乐

    那一年的她,家逢巨变。父母车祸,男友背叛。她彷徨无助,陷入绝望的深渊那一年的他,同她巷口初遇匆匆一瞥,心生惊艳.谁也不曾想过,重逢,会是那样不堪.谁也不曾知道,情动,究竟是哪一瞬间.后来……那一场爱恋,抵死纠缠.是他先开了头,又是他在懵懂中先丢了心他说:“游戏由我开始,就只能由我结束。”他还说:“做宠物,就要有做宠物的样子。”她反抗,她倔强。在遍体鳞伤后,学会了妥协和隐忍。而她,小心翼翼守着自己的心,却终究没能逃脱他的深情和强悍。
  • 戴牙箍的孩子

    戴牙箍的孩子

    本书从普通读者容易理解的角度出发,以牙齿矫治的程序为主线,分别介绍牙齿矫治前、中、后,家长和孩子该了解些什么及做些什么,并将口腔正畸学的基础知识、技术特点、患者顾虑和注意等问题融合其中。