登陆注册
20374300000020

第20章

Every action consists of three parts, some one of which must constitute the basis of whatever praise or blame we attribute to it. These three parts are: the intention or affection of the heart, from which the action proceeds;the external movement of the body which this affection causes; and the good or bad consequences which actually flow from it. It is evident that the movement of the body, being often the same in the most innocent as in the most blameable actions as in the case of shooting at a bird and shooting at a mancannot be the source of praise or blame. Neither can the accidental consequences of an action, which depend on fortune, not on the agent. The only consequences for which the latter is responsible are those in some way connected with his intention; so that it is to the intention or affection of the heart, to the propriety or impropriety, to the beneficence or hurt- fulness of the design, that all praise or blame, all approbation or disapprobation of any kind, must ultimately belong.

The problem then to be explained is the fact that our sense of a man's merit or demerit is at all influenced by re- suits which lie beyond his control, and that we moderate our praise or blame of his conduct according as his good or bad intention fails or not of its intended benefit or injury.

The explanation is as follows.

The passions of gratitude and resentment, on which depend our feeling of the merit or demerit of actions, are ultimately based on the bodily sensation of pleasure and pain. They are excited primarily by whatever produces pleasure or pain, even by inanimate objects. "We are angry for a moment even with the stone that hurts us. A child beats it, a dog barks at it, a choleric man is apt to curse it." We should feel guilty of a sort of inhumanity, if we neglected to avenge our friend by the destruction of the instrument that had accidently caused his death. So it is with gratitude.

A sailor who mended his fire with the plank that had saved him from shipwreck would seem guilty of an unnatural act, for we should expect him to preserve it with care and affection. So we conceive something like a real love and affection for a snuff-box, or pen-knife, or a stick, to which we have long been accustomed. "The house which we have long lived in, the tree whose verdure and shade we have long enjoyed, are both looked upon with a sort of respect which seems due to such benefactors. The decay of the one, or the ruin of the other, affects us with a kind of melancholy, though we should sustain no loss by it."Nevertheless to be the proper object of gratitude and resentment, a thing must not only be the cause of pleasure and pain, but itself capable of feeling them in return. Animals therefore are less improper objects of gratitude and resentment than inanimate things. "The dog that bites, the ox that gores, are both of them punished. If they have been the causes of the death of any person, neither the public, nor the relations of the slain, can be satisfied, unless they are put to death in their turn." And on the other hand, animals that have done a great service, are regarded with much gratitude; and we are shocked with the ingratitude of the officer, in the Turkish Spy , who stabbed the horse which had carried him across an arm of the sea, lest it should ever distinguish some other person by a similar feat.

But something more is still necessary to the complete gratification of gratitude and resentment than the mere capability for feeling pleasure or pain in return for pain or pleasure caused. The latter must have been caused by design, and there must be a consciousness of design in the return.

The object of resentment is chiefly not so much to make our enemy feel pain in his turn, as to make him conscious that he feels it upon account of his past conduct, and to make him repent of that conduct. And the chief object of gratitude is not only to make our benefactor feel pleasure in his turn, but to make him conscious that he meets with that reward on account of his past conduct, and to make him pleased with that conduct.

Hence three different qualifications are necessary to render anything the complete and proper object of gratitude or resentment. It must first of all be the cause of pleasure or pain; it must secondly be capable of feeling pleasure or pain; and it must thirdly produce pleasure or pain from a design, approved of in the one case or disapproved of in the other.

Since then the productiveness of pleasure or pain is the primary exciting cause of gratitude or resentment, though the intentions of any person should be ever so proper and beneficent, or ever so improper and malevolent, yet, if he has failed in producing the good or evil he intended, less gratitude or resentment seems due to him, or in other words, less merit or demerit seems to attach to him, because the pleasure or pain, the exciting causes of gratitude or resentment, are in either case wanting. And so, where in a man's intentions there has been no laudable benevolence or blameable malice, but his actions have nevertheless done great good or great evil, then some gratitude or resentment will attach to him, because their exciting causes have been present in either case. But since the consequences of a man's actions rest altogether with fortune, our sentiments of merit or demerit depend to a great extent upon her influence on events, upon her control of the good or bad, the pleasurable or painful results, which flow from our actions.

Thus the irregularity of our moral sentiments concerning the merit or demerit of actions depends ultimately on the accidental amount of pleasure or pain they produce, since these are the primary exciting causes of our gratitude or resentment. Having explained the cause of the phenomenon, it remains to illustrate the effects.

同类推荐
  • HIRAM THE YOUNG FARMER

    HIRAM THE YOUNG FARMER

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 静春堂集

    静春堂集

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 鲲溟诗集

    鲲溟诗集

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 吹剑录外集

    吹剑录外集

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 续大唐内典录

    续大唐内典录

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
热门推荐
  • 卿卿我的小娘子

    卿卿我的小娘子

    “卿卿,你终究还是爱上了我”,……“你回来吧,我什么都依你,”——“回不去了,她死了,我什么都没了!”日久,变之,生情。她穿越千年与他重逢,偶然相遇,却不识故人,一夜疯狂,日日流连,若干年的纠缠。她处处为他着想,他处处让她失望。她,因情逃离。他,为情所困。……卿,终究不肯为我停留?
  • 镇妖剑之行剑苍天

    镇妖剑之行剑苍天

    最后的剑侠,还原你年少的回忆与那轻薄的梦。
  • 乐此逍遥

    乐此逍遥

    被人告白,想了n种办法拒绝,谁知这姑娘还死缠烂打,最终看我如何逃离她?我只要金钱权利,至于美女,一边站。
  • 萌物养成,兔公主要抱抱

    萌物养成,兔公主要抱抱

    当一只英俊霸气又有型的食肉动物,遇上了一只呆萌蠢贱又可爱的食草动物,兔呆呆觉得,她过去的二十多年全都白活了。修大人宠她,宠到了骨子里。修大人虐她,让她感觉自己随时都有被吃掉的危险。是真的吃啊,他会对她露出尖尖的牙齿,舔一舔嗜血的嘴唇……兔呆呆表示,她这只食草动物,对俊美无比的食肉动物修大人,是又怕又爱,却也是个忠诚感十足的小迷妹。他们一起穿过森林,一起翻过高山,从此,一虎一兔,踏亡命天涯,自强不息的神奇之路。
  • 培养了不起的孩子

    培养了不起的孩子

    本书介绍了正确而科学的教育方法和理念。包括对孩子进行挫折教育,让孩子变得坚强而独立;根据孩子的特点进行教育,提高孩子的学习成绩;培养孩子的优势,让孩子更好的发展
  • 极品傲娇女友

    极品傲娇女友

    2016爆笑来袭!还是一样的欢乐,还是一样的感动!还记得那年七夕情人节,我们一起花前月下,你看着喜羊羊,哭着对我说:“为什么灰太狼不能和喜羊羊一起看星星看雪看月亮,从诗词歌赋谈到人生哲学?为什么真爱的羊与狼不能在一起?”“你从哪里看出喜羊羊和灰太狼是真爱的?”你委屈的看着我,泪眼婆娑,一把鼻涕一把泪往我身上摸着说:“你们男生真的不懂爱!”
  • 醉卧伊人怀

    醉卧伊人怀

    卑贱如泥的庶女,却被封为尊贵的皇子妃。攻无不克的战神,却被迫迎娶一个俘虏。他视她为狗,让她钻狗洞,睡狗棚,冷眼看着她毁去倾城容。父母惨死,姐妹反目,最爱的男人,将她死死锁在牢笼中。她活着的唯一意义,只剩下了战斗、复仇!他恨她是一条捂不热的毒蛇,没有心。她却笑他不知贱命难存,看不懂人心。
  • 邪魅总裁的夫人(全本)

    邪魅总裁的夫人(全本)

    坏蛋,混蛋,王八蛋。。。明明都已经分手了,为什么还来找她?明明是偶然遇到为什么说是她精心策划?这个自以为是的家伙真的是欠扁。。居然跑到她家去洗澡,最可气的是还把她关在了门外。。。摆脱,你要是看我不顺眼就揍我一顿吧,不要这样阴魂不散好不好?这个蠢女人还说什么是偶遇,明明就是故意的策划。。才和自己分手几天啊,就勾搭上了别的男人。。**********************************
  • 极品女特工

    极品女特工

    扑街写手穿越成废柴特工,痴情小子化身超级侦探,遭逢乱世岂能置身事外?一个是极品暖男,一个是百变大咖,一个是放荡版的林妹妹,一个是懵懂型的纯二货孰是孰非亦真亦假无法选择——乱世佳人以身犯险,细菌工厂以情动人,谁将执子之手,将子拖走?
  • 异世天娇

    异世天娇

    苦恋七年多,男友还是一朝劈腿。大受打击的苏苏无意中穿到了另一时空,这里光怪陆离却又险象丛生,完全弱势的她幸得空间在手。法宝秘籍,美男神仙,统统都到碗里来。且看一只菜鸟如何在异世成为一代大神,觅得良人的幸福生活。