登陆注册
20374300000051

第51章

Plato, Aristotle, and the Stoics, only regarded, in their account of virtue, that part of it which consists in propriety of conduct. According to Plato, the soul was composed of three different facultiesreason, passion, and appetite; and that higher form of justice which constitutes perfect virtue was nothing more than that state of mind in which every faculty confined itself to its proper sphere, without encroaching upon that of any other, and performed its office with precisely that degree of strength which belonged to it. In other words, this justice, the last and greatest of the cardinal virtues, and that which comprehended all the others, meant that exact and perfect propriety of conduct, the nature of which has been already discussed. Nearly the same account of virtue was given by Aristotle, who defined it as the habit of moderation in accordance with right reason;by which he meant a right affection of mind towards particular objects, as in being neither too much nor too little affected by objects of fear.

And the Stoics so far coincided with Plato and Aristotle as to place perfect virtue, or rectitude of conduct, in a proper choice or rejection of different objects and circumstances according as they were by nature rendered more or less the objects of our desire or aversion. In this propriety of the mind towards external things consisted the life according to nature, or in other words, the virtuous conduct of life.

No less incomplete than systems which placed virtue in propriety alone were those systems which placed it in prudence, or in a prudential regard for mere personal welfare. Such were the systems of the Cyrenaics and Epicureans in ancient times, and of writers like Hobbes and Mandeville in modern times.

According to Epicurus, the goodness or badness of anything was ultimately referable to its tendency to produce bodily pleasure or pain. Thus power and riches were desirable as good things, from their tendency to procure pleasure, whilst the evil of the contrary conditions lay in their close connexion with pain. Honour and reputation were of value, because the esteem of others was of so much importance to procure us pleasure and to defend us from pain. And in the same way the several virtues were not desirable simply for themselves, but only by reason of their intimate connexion with our greatest well-being, ease of body and tranquillity of mind. Thus temperance was nothing but prudence with regard to pleasure, the sacrifice of a present enjoyment to obtain a greater one or to avoid a greater pain. Courage was nothing but prudence with regard to danger or labour, not good in itself, but only as repellent of some greater evil. And justice too was nothing but prudence with regard to our neighbours, a means calculated to procure their esteem, and to avoid the fear that would flow from their resentment.

Adam Smith's first reply to this theory is, that whatever may be the tendency of the several virtues or vices, the sentiments which they excite in others are the objects of a much more passionate desire or aversion than all their other con- sequences; that to be-amiable and the proper object of esteem is of more value to us than all the ease and security which love or esteem can procure us: and that to be odious, or the proper object of contempt, or indignation is more dreadful than all we can suffer in our body from hatred, contempt, or indignation; and that therefore our desire of the one character and our aversion to the other cannot arise from regard to the effects which either of them is likely to produce on the body.

Secondly, there is one aspect of nature from which the Epicurean system derives its plausibility. "By the wise contrivance of the Author of nature, virtue is upon all ordinary occasions, even with regard to this life, real wisdom, and the surest and readiest means of obtaining both safety and advantage." The success or failure of our undertakings must very much depend on the good or bad opinion entertained of us, and on the general disposition of others to assist or oppose us. Hence the tendency of virtue to promote our interest and of vice to obstruct it, undoubtedly stamps an additional beauty and propriety upon the one, and a fresh deformity and im propriety upon the other. And thus temperance, magnanimity, justice and beneficence, come to be approved of, not only under their proper characters, but under the additional character of the most real prudence and the highest wisdom;whilst the contrary vices come to be disapproved of; not only under their proper characters, but under the additional character of the most short-sighted folly and weakness. So that the conduciveness of virtue to happiness is only secondary, and so to speak accidental to its character; it is not its first recommendation to our pursuit of it.

But if the theories which resolved virtue into propriety or prudence were thus one-sided, the remaining theorythat best represented by Hutchesonwas no less so, which made virtue to consist solely in benevolence, or in a disinterested regard to the good of others or the public generally. So far indeed did Hutcheson carry this theory, that he even rejected as a selfish motive to virtuous action the pleasure of self-approbation, "the comfortable applause of our own consciences," holding that it diminished the merit of any benevolent action. The principle of self-love could never be virtuous in any degree, and it was merely innocent, not good, when it led a man to act from a reasonable regard to his own happiness.

Several reasons seem, indeed, at first sight, to justify the identification of virtue with benevolence. It is the most agreeable of all the affections.

It is recommended to us by a double sympathy, and we feel it to be the proper object of gratitude and reward. Even its weakness or its excess is not very disagreeable to us, as is the excess of every other passion.

同类推荐
  • Volume Eight

    Volume Eight

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 译语

    译语

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 天方性理

    天方性理

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 道德真经解

    道德真经解

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 佛说魔逆经

    佛说魔逆经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
热门推荐
  • 凡可道

    凡可道

    得道容易证道难。修道即是修心。由心生慧,便可见洪荒本源。
  • 重生豪门复仇千金

    重生豪门复仇千金

    她,前世被闺蜜和男友所害。一睁眼,却变成了慕容家的的千金。这一世,她发誓要让她们生不如死。。
  • 萧张

    萧张

    再不疯狂我们就老了,没有回忆怎么祭奠啊!青春最悲哀的,不是我们做错了什么,而是什么也没做。“我叫萧张,萧何的萧,张良的张。”废柴学生萧张,大学狗一枚,11月11日光棍节,死于车祸。然屌丝如他,怨念太重。于是乎,上帝给了他重新来过的机会,这一次,他发誓,一定要好好风花雪月,嚣张一把,方不负他萧张之名。且看萧张重生之后如何嚣张,这一切的一切,尽在《萧张》!
  • 古剑奇谭:缘定今生

    古剑奇谭:缘定今生

    蓬莱大战,屠苏逝去,在所有人沉浸在一片悲伤之中,女娲大神降临天墉城告知百里屠苏三年后将会重生,只是他拥有的却是另一重身份——太子长琴。三年后兰生等人齐聚天墉城恭贺陵越登上掌门之位,空灵城大弟子陆子凌协同师弟们前来恭贺,当众人看着他的容颜亦是兴奋异常,那是屠苏的容貌,只是他却忘记了所有人,一场前所未有的天灾即将降落三界,拥有太子长琴仙灵的陆子凌、一直追寻着苏苏的晴雪、天墉城掌门陵越等人又一同上路,千年前长琴恋人南宫紫幽一路相随,面对着千年前的恋人,苏雪能否破镜重圆,他又能否记得前世最爱之人,堕落成魔的紫幽该何去何从,百里屠苏命魂能否顺利回归,古剑今生会给你们一个刻骨铭心之爱,执子之手与子偕老
  • 神元世界

    神元世界

    引子:我要讲的故事是发生在一个离我们很远的星球,在哪里没有我们现代生活中的各种高科技,但那里孕育了一股奇特的能量,这股能量就像西方的魔法和日本人口中的查克拉一样,那个大陆上的称这股能量叫做神元。在这里不崇拜金钱和权势,唯有你的个人实力才能获得大众的认可,唯有靠你的拳头才能征服这个世界,唯有靠你的天赋和后天的努力才能步上世界之巅。
  • 校花的贴身侍卫

    校花的贴身侍卫

    两千年前,秦国使者为秦皇寻长生灵药,遍寻仙山。虽未得长生灵药,但却寻得古医道法。此法,流传后世,人称古医。两千年后,古医唯一传人秦川开启古医血脉。以医术普度众生,以道法渡己渡人。古医重现,都市也因他一人风起云涌。
  • 掠爱成婚

    掠爱成婚

    一次陷害,苏玲走错房间……结婚前期,未婚夫车祸成废人。父亲卖女求荣,同父异母的白莲花妹妹,狠毒继母!神秘的未婚夫,冷酷无情,心狠手辣,“想逃?这辈子你只能是我的!”
  • 请给我1分钟:瞬间展示自我、看穿对手

    请给我1分钟:瞬间展示自我、看穿对手

    学会展示完美自己的技巧,熟练使用下去,使之成为一种习惯,续而成为一种本能,于是,在每一次会面中,你自然而然地展露出迷人的微笑、生动的眼神、无可挑剔的着装……一个完美的自己!本书主要内容包括首因效应:第一印象是长期交往的基础、示人以优:一分钟展示最美的自己、变短为长:一分钟让人刮目相看克服自卑、善辨真伪:一分钟洞察人心有的放矢、一锤定音:一分钟内塑造万人迷形象、交友之道:一分钟赢得好人缘、异性交往:一分钟打动他(她)的心等。
  • 都市最强特种兵

    都市最强特种兵

    “热血可洒,军令难违!我们是为和平而来!”维和、反恐,时常游走在危险边缘的杜希,佣兵界最强悍的敌人,各国元首最想要干掉的业内顶级兵王,卸下荣耀,回归家族后,却发现命运似乎也一直在和他作对。被自己家族视为耻辱,父母在家族抬不起头来、妹妹因为他交不到男朋友,未曾见过面的未婚妻一家,迫不及待跑来退婚,于是他怒了,他决定和这个世界谈谈,王者回归,携风云之势,一路啪啪啪拍打敌人的脸。
  • 益智录

    益智录

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。